MIAMI — The first Democratic presidential primary debates concluded on Thursday after an explosive night of heavyweight fights that reshaped the race for the nomination.
Here are the winners and losers after two hot nights in South Florida:
Sen. Kamala HarrisKamala Devi HarrisHarris spikes in Google search after Biden confrontation Trump campaign manager gloats after Biden-Harris exchange during Democrats’ debate Harris attacks Biden’s record on civil rights in debate MORE (Calif.)
Harris was patient, lying in wait until she sprung a direct attack on former Vice President Joe BidenJoe BidenHarris spikes in Google search after Biden confrontation Trump campaign manager gloats after Biden-Harris exchange during Democrats’ debate Biden pushes back on Obama’s climate record MORE’s record on civil rights in what turned out to be the most explosive exchange of either night.
It was a tense moment — Harris said that she took it personally when Biden said that he had found common ground working with segregationists in the Senate decades ago, and she contrasted Biden’s opposition to a federal busing law with her own experience with busing as a young minority girl growing up in California.
Biden called it a mischaracterization of his life’s work and reminded Harris that she had chosen to become a prosecutor, while he had pursued work as a public defender.
But Harris clearly won the exchange — she “eviscerated” him, as one Democrat told The Hill, and in the process announced herself as a direct challenger to the front-runner.
Harris also got the biggest laugh of the night after a shouting match among the candidates set her up to say, “America does not want to witness a food fight. They want to know how we are going to put food on their table.” Biden turned to her and clapped for that line.
Harris had been criticized coming into the debate for being too scripted and cautious. She was neither of those things on Thursday night and emerged as a clear winner on a stage that was loaded with top contenders. “She’s playing for keeps,” one Democrat told The Hill.
South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete ButtigiegPeter (Pete) Paul ButtigiegHarris spikes in Google search after Biden confrontation Dem candidates rip Trump on China ahead of crucial trade summit Buttigieg addresses South Bend police shooting in debate MORE
Buttigieg has been one of the biggest surprises in the campaign cycle so far, but he entered the night with a racially charged controversy hanging over his campaign.
The South Bend mayor addressed the officer-involved shooting of a black man in a straightforward way during the debate, taking direct responsibility for what he described as his own failure to address racial tensions between his city and the police department.
Buttigieg’s remarks won’t extinguish the “anguish” he said residents feel at home, but he struck the right tone for the national audience tuning in.
Elsewhere, Buttigieg came off as the bright, articulate and measured candidate that has earned him rave reviews from Washington insiders and propelled his unlikely ascendance on the national stage.
Sen. Elizabeth WarrenElizabeth Ann WarrenSanders, Harris, Biden only Dem debaters to favor eliminating private health insurance Overnight Health Care — Sponsored by Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids — What to watch for in tonight’s debate | Warren uses debate stage to embrace ‘Medicare for All’ | Gottlieb elected to Pfizer board | Democrats investigate Trump Medicaid changes Warren, Booker, Castro see favorability jump after first Democratic debate: poll MORE (Mass.)
Her poll numbers are up. Her policy proposals are a hit with the left. And now Warren has a strong debate performance under her belt.
Debating as the lone top contender on stage on Wednesday night ended up being a major boon for Warren, who stood out amid the weaker field of contenders.
The run-up to the debate couldn’t have gone much better for her, and all indications are she’ll continue that momentum into the next phase of the race.
Former Housing and Urban Development Secretary Julián Castro
Democrats have been eager to draw attention to the conditions for migrants held at detention facilities along the border.
Castro, the only Latino running for president, capitalized, pacing the field with his proposal to eliminate a statute that makes illegal entry into the U.S. a federal crime.
In a tense exchange on Wednesday night, Castro, a former mayor of San Antonio, cut down former Rep. Beto O’Rourke (Texas) for opposing repeal.
“I think that you should do your homework on this issue,” Castro said.
And he communicated his outrage at a viral photo that emerged this week of a father and daughter who drowned in the Rio Grande, saying it should “piss all of us off.”
Castro was trending on Twitter by the end of the night. A FiveThirtyEight analysis found that his approval rating jumped more than anyone else on the debate stage with him.
Former Vice President Joe Biden
Thursday night’s debate was not a complete disaster for Biden, but the expectations were highest for the front-runner and he leaves Miami looking vulnerable.
The media will want a competitive race and will magnify any misstep he makes, and Buttigieg and Harris both proved on Thursday night to be worthy alternatives for mainstream Democrats looking to shop around.
Biden missed an opportunity to knock out Rep. Eric SwalwellEric Michael Swalwell#PassTheTorch trends after Swalwell swipes at Biden during Democratic debate Harris admonishes opponents: Voters don’t want ‘a food fight’ Swalwell urges Biden to ‘pass the torch’ to younger generation MORE (Calif.), a low-polling contender who went after Biden for his age.
He said at one point that the National Rifle Association should not be seen as the enemy, which could come back to haunt him.
And his rivals repeatedly went after his decades-long record, leaving him playing defense on everything from civil rights to his vote to authorize military action in Iraq under President George W. Bush to the Obama administration’s legacy of deportations.
There is plenty of time for Biden to steady the ship. He has so far endured several controversies and gaffes with no material loss of support in the polls. But the race just got a lot more interesting for the front-runner.
Former Rep. Beto O’Rourke
“He got his butt kicked hard,” said CNN political analyst Van Jones.
O’Rourke repeatedly came out on the losing end of the most heated exchanges on Wednesday night. His rivals never thought twice about going after him.
Castro told O’Rourke, who comes from the border town of El Paso, that he needed to do his “homework” on immigration.
And after O’Rourke declined to say whether he would support a 70 percent tax on the wealthy, New York City Mayor Bill de BlasioBill de BlasioDelaney mocks Democrats at second debate: ‘These people are terrible at interrupting’ Sanders, Harris, Biden only Dem debaters to favor eliminating private health insurance Overnight Health Care — Sponsored by Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids — What to watch for in tonight’s debate | Warren uses debate stage to embrace ‘Medicare for All’ | Gottlieb elected to Pfizer board | Democrats investigate Trump Medicaid changes MORE jumped all over him.
“This is supposed to be the party of working people,” de Blasio said. “Yes, we’re supposed to be for a 70 percent tax rate on the wealthy.”
O’Rourke’s efforts at speaking Spanish went viral for all the wrong reasons, punctuated by Sen. Cory BookerCory Anthony BookerTrump campaign manager gloats after Biden-Harris exchange during Democrats’ debate Buttigieg opens second night of Democratic debate with first answer in Spanish Warren, Booker, Castro see favorability jump after first Democratic debate: poll MORE’s (D-N.J.) look as O’Rourke went back and forth between English and Spanish.
After entering the race with high hopes and a massive fundraising haul, Democrats on the floor of the spin room in Miami were whispering about whether O’Rourke’s campaign is too far gone to save.
Climate change activists
The Democratic National Committee has been under pressure to add a debate that focuses solely on climate change, and those calls will likely grow louder after the issue was largely relegated to the sidelines over the course of two nights in South Florida.
Democrats have cast climate change as an existential threat, with some saying it’s the most pressing geopolitical issue the U.S. faces.
But the Democrats spent fewer than 10 minutes on each night discussing their plans to address climate change, even though most of them have trillion-dollar plans to overhaul the U.S. economy on that front.
Even Washington Gov. Jay InsleeJay Robert InsleeMcConnell relishes role as 2020 debate villain Inslee defends comments calling Trump ‘biggest threat’ to US security Democratic debate takes heat for watered-down climate questions MORE, who’s made climate change his signature issue in the 2020 campaign, failed to talk about it on Wednesday night.
THE JURY IS OUT
Sen. Bernie SandersBernie SandersBernie Sanders says he would move to ‘rotate’ Supreme Court justices if elected Delaney mocks Democrats at second debate: ‘These people are terrible at interrupting’ Trump comments on Democratic debates during G-20 meeting with Merkel MORE (I-Vt.)
There were no surprises with Sanders on Thursday night.
He emphatically delivered the rhetoric on income inequality, “Medicare for All” and taxing the wealthy that thrills his supporters and spooks many mainstream Democrats, several of whom were on stage, such as former Colorado Gov. John HickenlooperJohn Wright HickenlooperHarris spikes in Google search after Biden confrontation Live coverage: 2020 candidates face off in second night of Democratic debates Swalwell: I won’t be ‘butchering Spanish’ during Democratic debate MORE and Sen. Michael BennetMichael Farrand BennetDem candidates rip Trump on China ahead of crucial trade summit Democrats whack Trump in second debate Michael Bennet taken by surprise with debate question: ‘Was that directed to me?’ MORE (Colo.)
But Sanders feels Warren rising in the polls, and there are questions about whether he will be able to rebuild the coalition that turned out for him with so much energy in 2016.
Sanders’s advisers and allies believe he’s being underestimated, but nothing about his debate performance on Thursday changed the dynamics for him.
Rep. Tulsi GabbardTulsi GabbardOvernight Defense: Senate passes 0B defense bill | Iran vote left for Friday | Democratic candidates talk Iran, Afghanistan at first debate | Congress moves toward tougher North Korea sanctions Trump campaign official: Democratic debate a ‘two-hour infomercial’ for president’s reelection Trump campaign official: Debate showed Democrats don’t ‘represent working Americans’ MORE (Hawaii)
Gabbard was the most searched candidate on Google on Wednesday night. But what does it mean?
Gabbard, an Iraq War veteran, clearly got the best of Rep. Tim RyanTimothy (Tim) John RyanOvernight Defense: Senate passes 0B defense bill | Iran vote left for Friday | Democratic candidates talk Iran, Afghanistan at first debate | Congress moves toward tougher North Korea sanctions Warren, Booker, Castro see favorability jump after first Democratic debate: poll McConnell relishes role as 2020 debate villain MORE (Ohio) in a heated exchange over U.S. involvement in foreign conflicts.
But much of the coverage of her debate performance was in the right-wing blogosphere. Gabbard won a Drudge Report straw poll, which is utterly meaningless in the Democratic primary, and she was praised for her anti-war stance by the libertarian magazine Reason.
None of that will do anything to endear her to the liberal base, but the media coverage is helpful for a candidate who has struggled mightily to be heard in the crowded field of 24.
Sen. Cory Booker (N.J.)
By most counts, Booker had a strong debate, reminding Democrats that he can be an effective and charismatic communicator when he’s on his game.
The problem is that Booker is languishing in the bottom tier of candidates and there was nothing from the debate to indicate his trajectory will change much in the near term.